One Sandwich - The Joy of Sandwiches
Sign up
Sign in Sign up

Cafe Benedict

Cafe in Cotati. 6 sandwiches, 3 wraps, 1 burger on the menu; the best scores 94.

Overhead of brunch plates: eggs Benedict, hummus and pita, falafel, a wrap with fries, French toast, mimosas
Photo: Cafe Benedict, from its Facebook page

Cafe · Cotati, Sonoma County

About

Cafe Benedict is a cafe in Cotati, independently owned. The site read its menu and scored every sandwich on it as the menu lists it; what follows is the menu, drawn and scored, not a review.

Type
Cafe
Where
Cotati, Sonoma County, California
Ownership
Independent
On the menu
6 sandwiches, 3 wraps, 1 burger; the best Sandwich Score is 94
Breads
toasted sourdough, brioche bun, warm tortilla, warm lavash bread, franco's bakery marble rye, sweet french roll, and 2 more
Provenance
1 house-made layer, 1 from a named producer by the menu's own wording
Worth a look
5 items with something notable
Menu
The menu this page was read from, read 2026-09 · Website
Directions
On Google Maps

Where it is

View on OpenStreetMap Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Particularly interesting

The sandwiches

  1. BLT-A 88 outstanding

    toasted sourdough, toasted: applewood smoked bacon; lettuce; tomato; mayo; avocado.

  2. Burger burger 90 legendary

    brioche bun, toasted: ½ lb certified angus beef (named producer); onions; romaine; tomato; pickles; mayo.

    Worth a look: named producer: Beef Patty (burger).

  3. Caesar Wrap wrap 56 solid

    warm tortilla, cold: chopped romaine lettuce; garlic croutons; shaved parmesan; caesar dressing (low tier); house marinated grilled chicken.

  4. Falafel Wrap wrap 91 legendary

    warm lavash bread, cold: homemade falafel (house-made); hummus; pickles; tomatoes; eggplant; seasoned cabbage; tahini sauce.

    Worth a look: house-made: Falafel.

  5. Grilled Cheese & Fries 44 rough

    bread not stated, toasted: cheese.

  6. Mediterranean Wrap wrap 80 excellent

    warm lavash bread, cold: marinated grilled chicken or gyro; sumac onions; pickles; tomatoes; choice of homemade tzatziki, tahini, garlic aioli.

    Worth a look: house-made: Tzatziki; ingredient not in the pantry: Sumac Onions.

  7. Reuben 94 legendary

    franco's bakery marble rye, toasted: corned beef brisket; swiss cheese; sauerkraut; 1000 islands dressing.

  8. Santa Fe Chicken 67 very good

    sweet french roll, cold: house marinated grilled chicken; roasted tomatoes; applewood smoked bacon; pepper jack cheese; avocado; lemon aioli.

    Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Lemon Aioli.

  9. The Melt 55 solid

    french roll, toasted: marinated grilled chicken or gyro meat; sautéed onions; pepper jack cheese; garlic aioli.

  10. Traditional Gyro Sandwich 84 excellent

    warm fresh gyro pita, cold: gyro meat; romaine lettuce; tomatoes; sumac onions; homemade tzatziki.

    Worth a look: house-made: Tzatziki; ingredient not in the pantry: Sumac Onions.

What you can build

Protein
marinated grilled chicken, gyro meat
Sauces
homemade tzatziki, tahini, garlic aioli

Menu read 2026-09; items and prices change. The Sandwich Score is the site's opinion of each recipe as the menu lists it, not a review of the shop. Tiers and house-made marks follow the menu's own wording.