One Sandwich - The Joy of Sandwiches
Sign up
Sign in Sign up

Buffalo Bill's Brewery

Restaurant in Hayward. 6 sandwiches, 1 wrap, 3 burgers on the menu; the best scores 92.

A bartender pours a foaming beer from the tap; a glass with the bison logo sits on the drip tray
Photo: Buffalo Bill's Brewery, from its website

Restaurant · Hayward, Alameda County

About

Buffalo Bill's Brewery is a restaurant in Hayward, independently owned. The site read its menu and scored every sandwich on it as the menu lists it; what follows is the menu, drawn and scored, not a review.

Type
Restaurant
Where
Hayward, Alameda County, California
Ownership
Independent
On the menu
6 sandwiches, 1 wrap, 3 burgers; the best Sandwich Score is 92
Breads
pretzel bun, ciabatta, spinach tortilla, brioche bun, odessa rye, grilled sourdough
Provenance
2 house-made layers, 3 from a named producer by the menu's own wording
Worth a look
6 items with something notable
Menu
The menu this page was read from, read 2026-09 · Website
Directions
On Google Maps

Where it is

View on OpenStreetMap Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Particularly interesting

The sandwiches

  1. Buffalo Bill's Burger burger 50 solid

    pretzel bun, toasted: durham ranch ground beef (named producer); bacon; cheddar.

    Worth a look: named producer: Ground Beef.

  2. Buffalo Chicken Sandwich 76 excellent

    ciabatta, cold: grilled chicken; bacon; pepper jack cheese; lettuce; onions; tomato; homemade spicy buffalo sauce (house-made); garlic aioli.

    Worth a look: house-made: Buffalo Sauce.

  3. Cheese Burger burger 53 solid

    pretzel bun, toasted: durham ranch ground beef (named producer); cheddar.

    Worth a look: named producer: Ground Beef.

  4. Chicken Wrap wrap 81 excellent

    spinach tortilla, cold: fried or grilled chicken breast; avocado; lettuce; pickled onions; cheddar cheese; chipotle sauce.

    Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Chipotle Sauce.

  5. Fried Chicken Sandwich 58 solid

    brioche bun, toasted: crispy chicken thigh; jalapenos; coleslaw; spicy honey glaze; garlic aioli.

  6. Jalapeno Burger burger 51 solid

    pretzel bun, toasted: durham ranch ground beef (named producer); bacon; blue cheese; roasted jalapenos; jalapeno jam.

    Worth a look: named producer: Ground Beef.

  7. Pastrami 75 very good

    odessa rye, cold: pastrami brisket; sauerkraut; swiss cheese; homemade horseradish (house-made); mayonnaise; brown mustard.

    Worth a look: house-made: Horseradish.

  8. Pesto Chicken Sandwich 59 solid

    ciabatta, cold: grilled chicken; pesto; sun-dried tomatoes; swiss cheese; lettuce; garlic aioli.

  9. Pulled Pork Sandwich 83 excellent

    ciabatta, cold: slow roasted pork shoulder; bbq sauce; jalapenos; coleslaw.

  10. Turkey Club 92 legendary

    grilled sourdough, toasted: oven roasted turkey; bacon; avocado; lettuce; tomato; onions; mayonnaise; jalapenos; brown mustard.

Menu read 2026-09; items and prices change. The Sandwich Score is the site's opinion of each recipe as the menu lists it, not a review of the shop. Tiers and house-made marks follow the menu's own wording.