A Jay's Cheese Steaks

Sandwich shop · Morgan Hill, Santa Clara County

Where it is

View on OpenStreetMap Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Particularly interesting

• Thai Spicy Curry (55): ingredient not in the pantry: Red Curry Sauce

The sandwiches

The typical sandwich here scores 65 (the median of 24 scored plainly). 2 items are listed without a number because the menu names them without describing them.

1. A-Jay's Burger burger 89 outstanding (much of this build is inferred)

   burger bun (not stated on the menu; inferred), toasted: 1/2 pound patty; choice of cheese; classic cheese steak; mayo; lettuce; tomatoes; pickles.

2. A-Jay's Classic Ribeye 56 solid (much of this build is inferred)

   french roll, toasted: thinly sliced ribeye; grilled onions; hot sweet cherry peppers; choice of cheese.

3. A-Jay's Dog hot dog 41 rough

   hot dog bun (not stated on the menu; inferred), toasted: charbroiled all-beef hot dog (low tier); classic cheese steak.

4. Aloha BBQ 61 solid

   french roll, toasted: classic ribeye; bbq sauce; bacon; pineapples; choice of cheese.

5. Avo Burger burger 88 outstanding (much of this build is inferred)

   burger bun (not stated on the menu; inferred), toasted: 1/2 pound patty; avocado; choice of cheese; mayo; lettuce; tomatoes; pickles.

6. BBQ 56 solid

   french roll, toasted: classic ribeye; bbq sauce; choice of cheese.

7. BLT 89 outstanding

   grilled sourdough, toasted: bacon; lettuce; tomato.

8. Bacon 46 rough

   french roll, toasted: classic ribeye; bacon; choice of cheese.

9. Bacon Cheese Burger burger 89 outstanding (much of this build is inferred)

   burger bun (not stated on the menu; inferred), toasted: 1/2 pound patty; bacon; choice of cheese; mayo; lettuce; tomatoes; pickles.

10. Beef Melt 89 outstanding

    grilled sourdough, toasted: beef; tomato; cheddar.

11. Buffalo 49 rough (much of this build is inferred)

    french roll, toasted: classic ribeye; buffalo sauce; choice of cheese.

12. Burger burger 89 outstanding

    burger bun (not stated on the menu; inferred), toasted: 1/2 pound patty; mayo; lettuce; tomatoes; pickles.

13. Californian 77 excellent

    french roll, toasted: classic ribeye; bacon; avocado; mayo; lettuce; tomato; choice of cheese.

14. Cheese Burger burger 89 outstanding (much of this build is inferred)

    burger bun (not stated on the menu; inferred), toasted: 1/2 pound patty; choice of cheese; mayo; lettuce; tomatoes; pickles.

15. Chicago Dog hot dog 73 very good

    hot dog bun (not stated on the menu; inferred), toasted: charbroiled all-beef hot dog (low tier); tomato; pickles; relish; onions; cheddar; peppers; mustard.

16. Chili Cheese Dog hot dog 45 rough

    hot dog bun (not stated on the menu; inferred), toasted: charbroiled all-beef hot dog (low tier); chili; cheddar or cheese whiz.

17. Chipotle Burger burger 88 outstanding (much of this build is inferred)

    burger bun (not stated on the menu; inferred), toasted: 1/2 pound patty; chipotle; choice of cheese; mayo; lettuce; tomatoes; pickles.

18. Grilled Cheese 45 rough

    grilled sourdough, toasted: cheese; butter.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (grilled cheese as it is served).

19. Hot Dog hot dog not scored: the menu does not describe a sandwich

    hot dog bun (not stated on the menu; inferred), toasted: 1/4 pound charbroiled all-beef hot dog (low tier).

20. Hot Link Sandwich 88 outstanding

    hoagie roll (not stated on the menu; inferred), toasted: charbroiled sylvia hot link sausage; mayo; tomato; lettuce; cheese choice.

21. Jalapeño Burger burger 89 outstanding (much of this build is inferred)

    burger bun (not stated on the menu; inferred), toasted: 1/2 pound patty; jalapeño; choice of cheese; mayo; lettuce; tomatoes; pickles.

22. Meatball Sub 74 very good

    french roll, toasted: italian meatballs; grilled onions; provolone; parmesan; marinara sauce.

23. Mushroom 52 solid

    french roll, toasted: classic ribeye; mushrooms; choice of cheese.

24. Mushroom Burger burger 89 outstanding

    burger bun (not stated on the menu; inferred), toasted: 1/2 pound patty; mushrooms; swiss; mayo; lettuce; tomatoes; pickles.

25. Pastrami 64 very good (much of this build is inferred)

    french roll, toasted: pastrami; grilled onions; hot sweet cherry peppers; mustard; choice of cheese.

26. Pastrami Burger burger 86 outstanding

    burger bun (not stated on the menu; inferred), toasted: 1/2 pound patty; pastrami; swiss; grilled onions; mustard; mayo; lettuce; tomatoes; pickles.

27. Pastrami Melt 70 very good

    grilled sourdough, toasted: pastrami; mustard; swiss.

28. Patty Melt 74 very good

    grilled sourdough, toasted: beef patty; grilled onions; swiss.

29. Pepper Steak 55 solid

    french roll, toasted: classic ribeye; bell peppers; choice of cheese.

30. Pizza 59 solid

    french roll, toasted: classic ribeye; marinara sauce; choice of cheese.

31. South County 55 solid

    french roll, toasted: classic ribeye; mushrooms; garlic; choice of cheese.

32. Teriyaki 51 solid

    french roll, toasted: classic ribeye; teriyaki sauce; choice of cheese.

33. Thai Spicy Curry 55 solid (much of this build is inferred)

    french roll, toasted: classic ribeye; bell peppers; thai spicy red curry sauce; choice of cheese.

    Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Red Curry Sauce.

34. The Dodgers Suck 55 solid (much of this build is inferred)

    french roll, toasted: classic ribeye; silva hot link sausage; bell peppers; choice of cheese.

35. Tijuana Dog hot dog 60 solid

    hot dog bun (not stated on the menu; inferred), toasted: charbroiled all-beef hot dog (low tier); bacon; jalepeno; cheddar; sour cream.

36. Turkey 54 solid (much of this build is inferred)

    french roll, toasted: turkey; grilled onions; hot sweet cherry peppers; choice of cheese.

37. Turkey Melt 68 very good

    grilled sourdough, toasted: turkey; avocado; tomato; cheddar.

38. Veggie not scored: the menu does not describe a sandwich

    french roll, toasted: mushrooms; zucchini; bell peppers; grilled onions; hot sweet cherry peppers; choice of cheese.

What you can build

Cheese

Provolone, White American, Cheese Whiz

Extras

Do It Hoagie Style (mayo, lettuce, tomato)

Protein

Ribeye, Chicken

Menu read 2026-09; items and prices change. The Sandwich Score is the site's opinion of each recipe as the menu lists it, not a review of the shop. Tiers and house-made marks follow the menu's own wording.