One Sandwich - The Joy of Sandwiches One Sandwich - The Joy of Sandwiches
Sign up
Sign in Sign up

Crogan's Montclair

Restaurant in Oakland. 12 sandwiches, 3 burgers on the menu; the best scores 94.

Bacon burger with salad in front, a cut sandwich behind, and a pint of Guinness on a dark wood table
Photo: Crogan's Montclair, from its website

Restaurant · Oakland, Alameda County

About

  • 15on the menu
  • 78typical Sandwich Score
  • 94best Sandwich Score
  • Atier, by the typical sandwich
  • 1house-made layer
  • 2layers from named producers
TypeRestaurant
WhereOakland, Alameda County, California
OwnershipIndependent
On the menu12 sandwiches, 3 burgers
Breadstoasted wheat, toasted sourdough, french roll, soft french roll, brioche bun, Hoagie Roll, and 4 more
Menu read2026-09

See the menuWebsiteDirections

Where it is

View on OpenStreetMap Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Particularly interesting

The sandwiches

The typical sandwich here scores 78 (the median of 14 scored plainly). 1 item is listed without a number because the menu names them without describing them.

  1. Bacon & Avocado Sandwich 89 outstanding

    toasted wheat, toasted: thick bacon slices; avocado; lettuce; tomato; mayonnaise.

  2. California Turkey Club Sandwich 89 outstanding

    toasted sourdough, toasted: sliced turkey; bacon; avocado; lettuce; tomato; mayonnaise.

  3. Chicken Sandwich 83 excellent

    french roll, cold: grilled chicken breast; avocado; bacon; pepper jack cheese; lettuce; sliced tomato.

  4. Crab Sandwich 85 outstanding

    toasted sourdough, toasted: atlantic blue crab; bacon; avocado; lettuce; tomato; chipotle aioli.

  5. Crispy Fried Chicken Sandwich 72 very good

    soft french roll, toasted: crispy buttermilk-marinated fried chicken breast; tomatoes; pickles; shredded lettuce (low tier); cholula aioli (named producer).

    Worth a look: named producer: Chili Aioli.

  6. Crogan's Hamburger burger 49 rough

    brioche bun, toasted: choice of ground beef, ground turkey or gardenburger patty; choice of cheese.

  7. Crogan's Kid Burger burger not scored: the menu does not describe a sandwich

    brioche bun, toasted: all-natural ground beef patty.

  8. Crogan's Philly Cheese Steak 58 solid

    hoagie roll (inferred from the name), toasted: sliced roast beef; bell peppers; onions; melted pepper jack cheese.

  9. French Dip Sandwich 67 very good

    soft french roll, toasted: in-house slow-roasted beef sliced thin (house-made); swiss cheese; au jus.

    Worth a look: house-made: Roast Beef.

  10. Fried Shrimp Po'Boy 51 solid

    soft french roll, toasted: battered shrimp; cholula aioli (named producer); shredded lettuce (low tier); tomato; pickles.

    Worth a look: named producer: Chili Aioli.

  11. Golden Bear Burger burger 59 solid

    brioche bun, toasted: ground beef hamburger patty; cheddar cheese; grilled onions; bacon.

  12. Grilled Cheese Sandwich 78 excellent

    sourdough bread, toasted: melted cheddar cheese; butter.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (grilled cheese as it is served).

  13. Pulled BBQ Pork Sandwich 89 outstanding

    toasted brioche bun, toasted: slow roasted pulled pork; sweet house bbq sauce; cole slaw; pickles.

  14. Reuben Sandwich 94 legendary

    toasted rye bread, toasted: house corned beef (high tier); swiss; russian dressing; sauerkraut.

  15. Steak Sandwich 77 excellent

    garlic buttered soft french roll, cold: sliced steak; garlic butter; cheddar cheese; grilled onions.

    Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Garlic Butter.

What you can build

Protein
ground beef, ground turkey, gardenburger

Menu read 2026-09; items and prices change. The Sandwich Score is the site's opinion of each recipe as the menu lists it, not a review of the shop. Tiers and house-made marks follow the menu's own wording.