Upper Crust Deli

Deli · Pacifica, San Mateo County

About

Upper Crust Deli is a deli in Pacifica, independently owned. The site read its menu and scored every sandwich on it as the menu lists it; what follows is the menu, drawn and scored, not a review.

Type

Deli

Where

Pacifica, San Mateo County, California

Ownership

Independent

On the menu

35 sandwiches, 4 wraps, 1 hot dog; the best Sandwich Score is 92

Breads

sourdough roll, white bread, toasted sourdough roll, dutch crunch roll, wrap, toasted sliced sourdough, and 8 more

Worth a look

4 items with something notable

Menu

The menu this page was read from, read 2026-09 · Website

Logo

Logo: Upper Crust Deli, from its website

Directions

On Google Maps

Where it is

View on OpenStreetMap Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Particularly interesting

• New York Steak Sandwich (63): house-made: NEW:House Sauce; ingredient not in the pantry: Jalapeño Spread, House Sauce
• Chicken With Chipotle Wrap (79): ingredient not in the pantry: Chipotle Onions
• Philly Cheese Turkey (64): ingredient not in the pantry: Ground Turkey

The sandwiches

1. BBQ Beef Sandwich 86 outstanding

   sourdough roll, toasted: roast beef; bbq sauce; mayo; mustard; pickle; tomato; lettuce; choice of cheese.

2. BBQ Chicken Sandwich 79 excellent

   sourdough roll, toasted: chicken breast; bbq sauce; mayo; mustard; pickle; tomato; lettuce; choice of cheese.

3. BLT Sandwich 78 excellent

   white bread, cold: bacon; lettuce; tomato; mayo.

4. Caesar Pastrami Sandwich 62 very good

   toasted sourdough roll, toasted: pastrami; pepper jack cheese; garlic spread; dijon mustard; lettuce; tomato; onion; jalapeño.

5. Chicken Ranch Melt Sandwich 79 excellent

   dutch crunch roll, toasted: char broiled chicken; bacon; ranch dressing (low tier); lettuce; tomato; mayo.

6. Chicken With Chipotle Wrap wrap 79 excellent

   wrap, cold: chicken; cheddar cheese; lettuce; tomato; bacon; chipotle onions; mayo.

   Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Chipotle Onions.

7. Corned Beef Sandwich 79 excellent

   bread not stated, cold: corned beef; mayo; mustard; pickle; tomato; lettuce; onion.

8. Egg Salad Sandwich 70 very good

   bread not stated, cold: egg salad; mayo; mustard; pickle; tomato; lettuce; onion.

9. Eggplant Delight Sandwich 56 solid

   toasted sliced sourdough, toasted: baked eggplant; spinach; garlic spread; tahini sauce; tomato; bell peppers; cucumbers.

10. Falafel Sandwich wrap 81 excellent

    wrap, cold: falafel balls; lettuce; tomato; tahini sauce; cucumber.

11. Grilled Chicken With BBQ Wrap wrap 82 excellent

    wrap, toasted: grilled chicken; bbq sauce; choice of cheese; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; mustard; mayo.

12. Grilled Pastrami Sandwich 55 solid

    bread not stated, toasted: grilled pastrami; sautéed onions; provolone.

13. Grilled Roast Beef Sandwich 91 legendary

    bread not stated, toasted: grilled roast beef; grilled onion; mayo; mustard; lettuce; tomato; pickle; melted provolone.

14. Honey Baked Ham Sandwich 58 solid

    bread not stated, cold: honey baked ham; mayo; mustard; pickle; tomato; lettuce; onion.

15. Honey Ham & Bacon Sandwich 79 excellent

    bread not stated, cold: honey ham; bacon; mayo; mustard; lettuce; tomato; pickle; onion; choice of cheese.

16. Italian Meatball Sandwich 80 excellent

    soft roll, cold: meatballs; tomato sauce; parmesan; mozzarella cheese.

17. Italian Meatloaf Sandwich 66 very good

    sourdough roll, cold: meatloaf; garlic spread; swiss cheese; mayo; pickle; tomato.

18. Kokuru Sandwich 69 very good

    toasted sourdough, toasted: oven roasted chicken breast; swiss cheese; mayo; dijon mustard; lettuce; tomato; pepperoncini.

19. New York Steak Sandwich 63 very good

    toasted roll, toasted: 8oz ny steak; melted pepper jack cheese; grilled onions; mushroom; jalapeño spread; home made sauce (high tier).

    Worth a look: house-made: NEW:House Sauce; ingredient not in the pantry: Jalapeño Spread, House Sauce.

20. Oven Roasted Chicken Breast Sandwich 58 solid

    bread not stated, cold: oven roasted chicken breast; mayo; mustard; pickle; tomato; lettuce; onion.

21. Pastrami Sandwich 71 very good

    bread not stated, cold: pastrami; mayo; mustard; pickle; tomato; lettuce; onion.

22. Patty Melt Sandwich 89 outstanding

    toasted rye, toasted: 1/3 pound patty; swiss; grilled onion; mayo; mustard; pickles.

23. Pepper Turkey Sandwich 60 solid

    bread not stated, cold: pepper turkey; mayo; mustard; lettuce; tomato; pickle; onion; choice of cheese.

24. Philly Cheese Chicken Breast 65 very good

    bread not stated, toasted: chicken breast; red and green peppers; pepperoncini; mushrooms; onions; provolone cheese.

25. Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich 82 excellent

    bread not stated, toasted: 1/2 lb ribeye; red and green peppers; pepperoncini; mushrooms; mayo; onions; provolone cheese.

26. Philly Cheese Turkey 64 very good

    bread not stated, toasted: ground turkey; red and green peppers; pepperoncini; mushrooms; onions; provolone cheese.

    Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Ground Turkey.

27. Reuben Sandwich 92 legendary

    toasted rye bread, toasted: pastrami; swiss cheese; sauerkraut; mustard; mayo.

28. Roast Beef Sandwich 84 excellent

    bread not stated, cold: roast beef; mayo; mustard; pickle; tomato; lettuce; onion.

29. Sicilian Love Sandwich 72 very good

    sourdough roll, cold: bologna; ham; mortadella (high tier); salami; provolone cheese; pesto spread; lettuce; tomato; pepperoncini; onion.

30. Smoked Turkey & Bacon Sandwich 78 excellent

    bread not stated, cold: smoked turkey; bacon; mayo; mustard; lettuce; tomato; pickle; onion; choice of cheese.

31. Steak Wrap wrap 68 very good

    wrap, cold: 1/2 pound ribeye; choice of cheese; mushrooms; onions; lettuce; mayo.

32. Sunny Pacifica Sandwich 76 excellent

    dutch crunch roll, cold: corned beef; swiss cheese; garlic spread; mayo; lettuce; tomato; cucumbers; onions.

33. Superlink hot dog 73 very good

    toasted sourdough roll, toasted: two links; melted american cheese (low tier); mayo; mustard; lettuce; tomato; pickle; onion; ketchup (low tier).

34. TN Tiger Special Sandwich 81 excellent

    toasted soft roll, toasted: turkey; ham; bacon; avocado; mayo; mustard; black pepper.

35. The Club Sandwich 82 excellent

    toasted white bread, toasted: turkey; ham; bacon; mayo; dijon mustard; tomato; lettuce.

36. Tri Tip Steak Sandwich 64 very good

    toasted roll, toasted: charbroiled tri tip steak; grilled onions; mushrooms; garlic; jalapeños; chipotle.

    Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Chipotle.

37. Tuna Salad Sandwich 80 excellent

    bread not stated, cold: tuna salad; mayo; mustard; pickle; tomato; lettuce; onion.

38. Turkey Sandwich 72 very good

    bread not stated, cold: turkey; mayo; mustard; pickle; tomato; lettuce; onion.

39. Two Bridges Sandwich 63 very good

    sourdough roll, cold: turkey; ham; roast beef; monterey jack cheese; american cheese (low tier); lettuce; tomato; pickles; mayo; mustard.

40. Vegetarian Sandwich 56 solid

    wheat bread, cold: avocados; sprouts; cucumbers; lettuce; onion; tomatoes; pesto spread; olive oil dressing.

Menu read 2026-09; items and prices change. The Sandwich Score is the site's opinion of each recipe as the menu lists it, not a review of the shop. Tiers and house-made marks follow the menu's own wording.