Sandwich shop · Redwood City, San Mateo County
About
The Sandwich Guy is a sandwich shop in Redwood City, independently owned. The site read its menu and scored every sandwich on it as the menu lists it; what follows is the menu, scored, not a review.
- 16on the menu
- 76typical Sandwich Score
- 84best Sandwich Score
- Atier, by the typical sandwich
| Type | Sandwich shop |
|---|---|
| Where | Redwood City, San Mateo County, California |
| Ownership | Independent |
| On the menu | 16 sandwiches |
| Breads | choice of bread |
| Menu read | 2026-09 |
Where it is
View on OpenStreetMap Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.
The sandwiches
The typical sandwich here scores 76 (the median of 11 scored plainly). 1 item is listed without a number because the menu names them without describing them.
-
Beef Meat Ball 64 very good (much of this build is inferred)
hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), toasted: beef meatballs; melted cheese of your choice; mayo; mustard; onion; pickles; peppers.
-
Chicken Breast 64 very good (much of this build is inferred)
hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), toasted: chicken breast; melted cheese of your choice; mayo; mustard; onion; pickles; peppers.
-
Chicken Salad 71 very good
hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: chicken salad; mayo; mustard; lettuce; tomatoes; onion; pickles; pepperoncini.
-
Classic B.L.T 79 excellent
white bread (inferred from the name), toasted: bacon; lettuce; tomatoes; mayo; mustard; onion; pickles; pepperoncini.
-
Godfather 76 excellent
hoagie roll (inferred from the name), cold: salami; prosciutto (high tier); mayo; mustard; lettuce; tomatoes; onion; pickles; pepperoncini.
-
Ham & Cheese 78 excellent
hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: ham; cheese; mayo; mustard; lettuce; tomatoes; onion; pickles; pepperoncini.
-
Hot Pastrami 64 very good (much of this build is inferred)
hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), toasted: hot pastrami; melted cheese of your choice; mayo; mustard; onion; pickles; peppers.
-
Mortadella 69 very good
hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: mortadella (high tier); mayo; mustard; lettuce; tomatoes; onion; pickles; pepperoncini.
-
Pastrami Brisket 71 very good
hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: pastrami brisket; mayo; mustard; lettuce; tomatoes; onion; pickles; pepperoncini.
-
Reuben 60 solid
rye bread (inferred from the name), toasted: melted cheese; sauerkraut; dressing; mayo; mustard; onion; pickles; peppers.
-
Roast Beef 84 excellent
hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: roast beef; mayo; mustard; lettuce; tomatoes; onion; pickles; pepperoncini.
-
Salami & Cheese 76 excellent
hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: salami; cheese; mayo; mustard; lettuce; tomatoes; onion; pickles; pepperoncini.
-
Tuna Melt 75 very good (much of this build is inferred)
white bread (inferred from the name), toasted: tuna; melted cheese of your choice; mayo; mustard; onion; pickles; peppers.
-
Tuna Salad 80 excellent
hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: tuna salad; mayo; mustard; lettuce; tomatoes; onion; pickles; pepperoncini.
-
Turkey 72 very good
hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: turkey (honey, peppered or classic); mayo; mustard; lettuce; tomatoes; onion; pickles; pepperoncini.
-
Veggie Sandwich not scored: the menu does not describe a sandwich
hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: mayo; mustard; lettuce; tomatoes; onion; pickles; pepperoncini.
What you can build
- Bread
- sourdough roll, dutch crunch roll, sweet roll, sourdough slice, wheat roll, wheat slice, light rye
- Cheese
- swiss, provolone, cheddar, monterey jack, pepper jack, smoked cheddar, american
- Produce
- lettuce, tomatoes, onion, pickles, pepperoncini
- Sauces
- mayo, mustard
The standard build, if you say nothing: mayo, mustard, lettuce, tomatoes, onion, pickles, pepperoncini.