Cafe · San Francisco, San Francisco County
About
Castro Tarts is a cafe in San Francisco, independently owned. The site read its menu and scored every sandwich on it as the menu lists it; what follows is the menu, drawn and scored, not a review.
- Type
- Cafe
- Where
- San Francisco, San Francisco County, California
- Ownership
- Independent
- On the menu
- 20 sandwiches; the best Sandwich Score is 90
- Breads
- Bánh Mì Baguette, choice of bread, Hoagie Roll
- Provenance
- 12 house-made layers by the menu's own wording
- Worth a look
- 14 items with something notable
- Menu
- The menu this page was read from, read 2026-09 · Website
- Directions
- On Google Maps
Where it is
View on OpenStreetMap Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.
Particularly interesting
- Ginger Chicken Breast (78): house-made: Pickled Carrot; ingredient not in the pantry: Ginger Chicken
- BBQ Pork (90): house-made: Pickled Carrot
- BBQ Beef (89): house-made: Pickled Carrot
The sandwiches
-
Asian Pate 87 outstanding
Bánh Mì Baguette (bread not stated on the menu), cold: asian pate; homemade sweet and sour carrots (house-made); cucumber; cilantro; mayo.
Worth a look: house-made: Pickled Carrot.
-
BBQ Beef 89 outstanding
Bánh Mì Baguette (bread not stated on the menu), toasted: bbq beef; homemade sweet and sour carrots (house-made); cucumber; cilantro; mayo.
Worth a look: house-made: Pickled Carrot.
-
BBQ Pork 90 legendary
Bánh Mì Baguette (bread not stated on the menu), toasted: bbq pork; homemade sweet and sour carrots (house-made); cucumber; cilantro; mayo.
Worth a look: house-made: Pickled Carrot.
-
BBQ Pork With Egg 89 outstanding
Bánh Mì Baguette (bread not stated on the menu), toasted: bbq pork; egg; homemade sweet and sour carrots (house-made); cucumber; cilantro; mayo.
Worth a look: house-made: Pickled Carrot.
-
BLT 84 excellent
choice of bread, cold: bacon; lettuce; tomato; mayo.
-
Black Forest Ham 86 outstanding
bread not stated, cold: black forest ham; lettuce; tomato; red bell pepper; provolone cheese; mayo; mustard.
-
Combo Ham 78 excellent
Bánh Mì Baguette (bread not stated on the menu), cold: combo ham; homemade sweet and sour carrots; cucumber; cilantro; mayo.
Worth a look: house-made: Pickled Carrot.
-
Combo Vegetables 57 solid
bread not stated, cold: tofu; lettuce; tomato; mayo; mustard.
-
Fried Egg 86 outstanding
Bánh Mì Baguette (bread not stated on the menu), toasted: fried egg; homemade sweet and sour carrots (house-made); cucumber; cilantro; mayo.
Worth a look: house-made: Pickled Carrot.
-
Ginger Chicken Breast 78 excellent
Bánh Mì Baguette (bread not stated on the menu), cold: ginger chicken breast; homemade sweet and sour carrots; cucumber; cilantro; mayo.
Worth a look: house-made: Pickled Carrot; ingredient not in the pantry: Ginger Chicken.
-
Lemon Grass Chicken 78 excellent
Bánh Mì Baguette (bread not stated on the menu), cold: lemon grass chicken; homemade sweet and sour carrots (house-made); cucumber; cilantro; mayo.
Worth a look: house-made: Pickled Carrot.
-
Lemongrass Pork Loin 78 excellent
Bánh Mì Baguette (bread not stated on the menu), cold: lemongrass pork loin; homemade sweet and sour carrots (house-made); cucumber; cilantro; mayo.
Worth a look: house-made: Pickled Carrot.
-
Meatball 89 outstanding
Bánh Mì Baguette (bread not stated on the menu), cold: meatball; homemade sweet and sour carrots (house-made); cucumber; cilantro; mayo.
Worth a look: house-made: Pickled Carrot.
-
Philly Cheese Steak 83 excellent
Hoagie Roll (bread not stated on the menu), toasted: steak; provolone cheese; mushroom; onion; bell pepper; mayo.
-
Roasted Chicken 78 excellent
Bánh Mì Baguette (bread not stated on the menu), cold: roasted chicken; homemade sweet and sour carrots (house-made); cucumber; cilantro; mayo.
Worth a look: house-made: Pickled Carrot.
-
Roasted Pork 89 outstanding
Bánh Mì Baguette (bread not stated on the menu), cold: roasted pork; homemade sweet and sour carrots (house-made); cucumber; cilantro; mayo.
Worth a look: house-made: Pickled Carrot.
-
Rosemary Chicken Breast 78 excellent
Bánh Mì Baguette (bread not stated on the menu), cold: rosemary chicken breast; homemade sweet and sour carrots (house-made); cucumber; cilantro; mayo.
Worth a look: house-made: Pickled Carrot.
-
Smoked Salmon 61 solid
bread not stated, cold: smoked salmon; mixed greens; tomato; onion; mayo.
-
Tofu 79 excellent
Bánh Mì Baguette (bread not stated on the menu), cold: tofu; homemade sweet and sour carrots (house-made); cucumber; cilantro; mayo.
Worth a look: house-made: Pickled Carrot.
-
Turkey Club 87 outstanding
bread not stated, cold: turkey; bacon; lettuce; tomato; provolone cheese; mayo; mustard.