Gambino's New York Subs

Sandwich shop · San Francisco, San Francisco County

About

Gambino's New York Subs is a sandwich shop in San Francisco, independently owned. The site read its menu and scored every sandwich on it as the menu lists it; what follows is the menu, drawn and scored, not a review.

Type

Sandwich shop

Where

San Francisco, San Francisco County, California

Ownership

Independent

On the menu

29 sandwiches, 1 burger; the best Sandwich Score is 88

Breads

choice of bread, premium soft roll, sub roll

Menu

The menu this page was read from, read 2026-09 · Website

Directions

On Google Maps

Where it is

View on OpenStreetMap Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

The menu, drawn

• BLT 88
• Baked Eggplant Parm 58
• Boston Bulger 39
• Cheese Steak 61
• Chicken Cheese Steak 56
• Chicken Parm 78
• Chipotle Turkey 50
• Final Stop 51
• Five Points 39
• Gentleman's Sub 64
• Ham & Cheese 64
• Ham, Cappicola & Cheese 43
• Meatball Parm 81
• Montauk 38
• Mortadella, Salami & Cheese 41
• Mulberry St. 62
• Pastrami & Swiss 67
• Pepperoni & Cheese 60
• Prosciutto & Cheese 60
• Roast Beef & Cheese 60
• Roast Beef, Turkey & Cheese 37
• Salami, Ham & Cheese 42
• Sausage With Onion & Peppers 60
• The Gambino 46
• The Italian 46
• Tribeca 50
• Turkey & Cheese 57
• Turkey, Hot Coppa & Cheese 46
• Ultimate Cheese Burger 59
• Vegetarian Wreck 35

The sandwiches

1. BLT 88 outstanding

   choice of bread, toasted: bacon; lettuce; tomato.

2. Baked Eggplant Parm 58 solid

   choice of bread, toasted: eggplant; marinara sauce; parmesan cheese.

3. Boston Bulger 39 rough

   choice of bread, cold: roast beef; gorgonzola cheese; roasted red peppers.

4. Cheese Steak 61 solid

   premium soft roll, toasted: premium sirloin steak; five cheese blend; grilled onions; grilled bell peppers.

5. Chicken Cheese Steak 56 solid

   choice of bread, toasted: grilled chicken; custom house cheese blend; grilled onions; peppers.

6. Chicken Parm 78 excellent

   choice of bread, toasted: chicken; marinara sauce; parmesan cheese.

7. Chipotle Turkey 50 solid

   choice of bread, toasted: turkey; bacon; gouda.

8. Final Stop 51 solid

   choice of bread, cold: Ham; Turkey; Capicola (coppa) (high tier); Mortadella (high tier); Mozzarella; Basil; Balsamic (vinegar, glaze).

9. Five Points 39 rough

   choice of bread, cold: turkey; ham; roast beef; provolone.

10. Gentleman's Sub 64 very good

    choice of bread, toasted: prosciutto (high tier); fresh mozzarella (high tier); basil; balsamic vinaigrette.

11. Ham & Cheese 64 very good

    choice of bread, cold: ham; cheese; shredded lettuce (low tier); tomato; onion.

12. Ham, Cappicola & Cheese 43 rough

    choice of bread, cold: ham; cappicola (high tier); cheese.

13. Meatball Parm 81 excellent

    choice of bread, toasted: meatballs; marinara sauce; parmesan cheese.

14. Montauk 38 rough

    choice of bread, cold: Tuna Salad; Olive Oil.

15. Mortadella, Salami & Cheese 41 rough

    choice of bread, cold: mortadella (high tier); salami; cheese.

16. Mulberry St. 62 very good

    choice of bread, cold: fresh mozzarella (high tier); basil; tomato; balsamic vinaigrette.

17. Pastrami & Swiss 67 very good

    choice of bread, toasted: pastrami; swiss cheese; shredded lettuce (low tier); tomato; onion.

18. Pepperoni & Cheese 60 solid

    choice of bread, cold: pepperoni; cheese; shredded lettuce (low tier); tomato; onion.

19. Prosciutto & Cheese 60 solid

    choice of bread, cold: prosciutto (high tier); cheese; shredded lettuce (low tier); tomato; onion.

20. Roast Beef & Cheese 60 solid

    choice of bread, cold: roast beef; cheese; shredded lettuce (low tier); tomato; onion.

21. Roast Beef, Turkey & Cheese 37 rough

    choice of bread, cold: roast beef; turkey; cheese.

22. Salami, Ham & Cheese 42 rough

    choice of bread, cold: salami; ham; cheese.

23. Sausage With Onion & Peppers 60 solid

    choice of bread, toasted: sausage; onion; peppers.

24. The Gambino 46 rough

    choice of bread, cold: ham; salami; hot coppa; mortadella (high tier); provolone.

25. The Italian 46 rough

    choice of bread, cold: mortadella (high tier); cappicola (high tier); salami; pepperoni; provolone.

26. Tribeca 50 solid

    choice of bread, cold: chicken; basil; balsamic vinaigrette; provolone cheese; roasted red peppers.

27. Turkey & Cheese 57 solid

    choice of bread, cold: turkey; cheese; shredded lettuce (low tier); tomato; onion.

28. Turkey, Hot Coppa & Cheese 46 rough

    choice of bread, toasted: turkey; hot coppa; cheese.

29. Ultimate Cheese Burger burger 59 solid

    sub roll, toasted: Beef; Any cheese; Onion; Pepper (bell/hot).

30. Vegetarian Wreck 35 rough

    choice of bread, cold: eggplant; mushroom; artichokes; roasted peppers.

What you can build

Bread

soft sub roll, italian hard roll, wheat roll, dutch crunch

How it is served

east coast style, west coast style, traditional toasted in pizza oven

Produce

shredded lettuce, sliced tomatoes, onions, pickles, hots, pepperoncini

Sauces

olive oil, vinegar, herbs, salt and pepper, mayo, mustard

Cheese

gambino's custom house cheese blend on all hot subs

Protein

bacon, avocado

Menu read 2026-09; items and prices change. The Sandwich Score is the site's opinion of each recipe as the menu lists it, not a review of the shop. Tiers and house-made marks follow the menu's own wording.