Corner store · San Francisco, San Francisco County
About
Mayflower Market is a corner store in San Francisco, independently owned. The site read its menu and scored every sandwich on it as the menu lists it; what follows is the menu, drawn and scored, not a review.
- Type
- Corner store
- Where
- San Francisco, San Francisco County, California
- Ownership
- Independent
- On the menu
- 31 sandwiches, 1 burger; the best Sandwich Score is 94
- Breads
- choice of bread
- Provenance
- 2 house-made layers by the menu's own wording
- Worth a look
- 6 items with something notable
- Menu
- The menu this page was read from, read 2026-09 · Website
- Directions
- On Google Maps
Where it is
View on OpenStreetMap Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.
Particularly interesting
- Sausalito Turkey: named producer: NEW:Sausalito Turkey; ingredient not in the pantry: Sausalito Turkey
- Tuna Melt (48): house-made: Tuna Salad
- Chicken Salad (39): house-made: Chicken Salad
The sandwiches
-
B.L.T. 84 excellent
choice of bread, cold: bacon; lettuce; tomato; mayo.
-
Black Forest Ham 37 rough
choice of bread, cold: black forest ham.
-
Bologna 37 rough
choice of bread, cold: bologna.
-
Chicken Breast 34 chaos
choice of bread, cold: chicken breast.
-
Chicken Breast Fillet 37 rough
choice of bread, cold: chicken breast; cheese.
-
Chicken Salad 39 rough
choice of bread, cold: homemade chicken salad made from rotisserie chickens (house-made).
Worth a look: house-made: Chicken Salad.
-
Club Sandwich 55 solid
choice of bread, cold: turkey; cheese; lettuce; tomato.
-
Corned Beef 32 chaos
choice of bread, cold: corned beef.
-
Egg Salad Sandwich 39 rough
choice of bread, cold: egg salad.
-
Garden Burger burger 51 solid
choice of bread, toasted: vegetarian patty; lettuce; tomato.
-
Garlic and Herb Turkey Sandwich 35 rough
choice of bread, cold: garlic and herb turkey; cheese.
-
Ham 37 rough
choice of bread, cold: ham.
-
Hot Chicken Cordon Bleu 50 solid
choice of bread, toasted: breaded chicken; swiss; ham.
-
Italian Sub 43 rough
choice of bread, cold: mortadella (high tier); bologna; salami; ham; provolone.
-
Maple Ham not scored: no layer the pantry knows
choice of bread, cold: maple ham.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Maple Ham.
-
Maple Turkey not scored: no layer the pantry knows
choice of bread, cold: maple turkey.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Maple Turkey.
-
Meatball Sub 37 rough
choice of bread, cold: meatballs; cheese.
-
Meatloaf Sub 37 rough
choice of bread, cold: meatloaf; cheese.
-
Mortadella 38 rough
choice of bread, cold: mortadella (high tier).
-
NY Pastrami 34 chaos
choice of bread, cold: ny pastrami.
-
Pepper Turkey not scored: no layer the pantry knows
choice of bread, cold: pepper turkey.
-
Reuben 94 legendary
choice of bread, toasted: corned beef; swiss; sauerkraut; russian dressing.
-
Roast Beef 34 chaos
choice of bread, cold: roast beef.
-
Salami 36 rough
choice of bread, cold: salami.
-
Sausalito Turkey not scored: no layer the pantry knows
choice of bread, cold: sausalito turkey.
Worth a look: named producer: NEW:Sausalito Turkey; ingredient not in the pantry: Sausalito Turkey.
-
Seafood Salad Sandwich not scored: no layer the pantry knows
choice of bread, cold: imitation crab salad.
Worth a look: rare in the Bay Area (5 or fewer shops): Imitation Crab (surimi).
-
Smoked Turkey 33 chaos
choice of bread, cold: smoked turkey.
-
Texican Melt 65 very good
choice of bread, toasted: roast beef; cheddar; bbq sauce; bacon.
-
Tuna 39 rough
choice of bread, cold: tuna.
-
Tuna Melt 48 rough
choice of bread, toasted: homemade tuna salad (house-made); choice of cheese.
Worth a look: house-made: Tuna Salad.
-
Turkey 33 chaos
choice of bread, cold: turkey.
-
Vegetarian 68 very good
choice of bread, cold: mayo; mustard; avocado; sprouts; lettuce; tomato; pickles; peppers; onions; cheese.
What you can build
- Bread
- soft roll, sourdough roll, dutch crunch, whole wheat, white, sourdough, dark rye, light rye
- Cheese
- cheddar, american, jack, pepperjack, provolone, swiss
- Extras
- bacon
- Produce
- avocado, cranberry, jalapeños, sprouts
- Protein
- salami, ham, corned beef, turkey, tuna, bologna, ny pastrami, chicken breast, mortadella, smoked turkey, maple turkey, pepper turkey, maple ham, sausalito turkey, roast beef, black forest ham
- Sauces
- bbq sauce, thousand island, yellow mustard, dijon mustard, honey mustard