One Sandwich - The Joy of Sandwiches
Sign up
Sign in Sign up

Mayflower Market

Corner store in San Francisco. 31 sandwiches, 1 burger on the menu; the best scores 89.

Corner store · San Francisco, San Francisco County

About

Mayflower Market is a corner store in San Francisco, independently owned. The site read its menu and scored every sandwich on it as the menu lists it; what follows is the menu, scored, not a review.

  • 32on the menu
  • 62typical Sandwich Score
  • 89best Sandwich Score
  • Btier, by the typical sandwich
  • 2house-made layers
TypeCorner store
WhereSan Francisco, San Francisco County, California
OwnershipIndependent
On the menu31 sandwiches, 1 burger
Breadschoice of bread
Menu read2026-09

See the menuWebsiteDirections

Where it is

View on OpenStreetMap Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Particularly interesting

The sandwiches

The typical sandwich here scores 62 (the median of 11 scored plainly). 6 items are listed without a number because the menu names them without describing them.

  1. B.L.T. 89 outstanding

    white bread (inferred from the name), toasted: bacon; lettuce; tomato; mayo.

  2. Black Forest Ham 89 outstanding (much of this build is inferred)

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: black forest ham; lettuce; tomato; mayonnaise; mustard.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (the deli standard for a lone protein).

  3. Bologna 89 outstanding (much of this build is inferred)

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: bologna; lettuce; tomato; mayonnaise; mustard.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (the deli standard for a lone protein).

  4. Chicken Breast 77 excellent (much of this build is inferred)

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: chicken breast; lettuce; tomato; mayonnaise; mustard.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (the deli standard for a lone protein).

  5. Chicken Breast Fillet 46 rough

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: chicken breast; cheese.

  6. Chicken Salad 76 excellent (much of this build is inferred)

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: homemade chicken salad made from rotisserie chickens (house-made); lettuce; tomato; mayonnaise; mustard.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (the deli standard for a lone protein).

    Worth a look: house-made: Chicken Salad.

  7. Club Sandwich 62 very good

    white bread (inferred from the name), toasted: turkey; cheese; lettuce; tomato.

  8. Corned Beef 89 outstanding (much of this build is inferred)

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: corned beef; lettuce; tomato; mayonnaise; mustard.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (the deli standard for a lone protein).

  9. Egg Salad Sandwich not scored: the menu does not describe a sandwich

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), toasted: egg salad.

  10. Garden Burger burger 62 very good

    burger bun (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), toasted: vegetarian patty; lettuce; tomato.

  11. Garlic and Herb Turkey Sandwich 46 rough

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: garlic and herb turkey; cheese.

  12. Ham 89 outstanding (much of this build is inferred)

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: ham; lettuce; tomato; mayonnaise; mustard.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (the deli standard for a lone protein).

  13. Hot Chicken Cordon Bleu 51 solid

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), toasted: breaded chicken; swiss; ham.

  14. Italian Sub 54 solid

    hoagie roll (inferred from the name), cold: mortadella (high tier); bologna; salami; ham; provolone.

  15. Maple Ham not scored: the menu does not describe a sandwich

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: maple ham; lettuce; tomato; mayonnaise; mustard.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (the deli standard for a lone protein).

    Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Maple Ham.

  16. Maple Turkey not scored: the menu does not describe a sandwich

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: maple turkey; lettuce; tomato; mayonnaise; mustard.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (the deli standard for a lone protein).

    Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Maple Turkey.

  17. Meatball Sub 84 excellent (much of this build is inferred)

    hoagie roll (inferred from the name), toasted: meatballs; cheese; marinara; provolone.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (meatball sub as it is served).

  18. Meatloaf Sub 47 rough

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: meatloaf; cheese.

  19. Mortadella 74 very good (much of this build is inferred)

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: mortadella (high tier); lettuce; tomato; mayonnaise; mustard.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (the deli standard for a lone protein).

  20. NY Pastrami 89 outstanding (much of this build is inferred)

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: ny pastrami; lettuce; tomato; mayonnaise; mustard.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (the deli standard for a lone protein).

  21. Pepper Turkey not scored: the menu does not describe a sandwich

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: pepper turkey; lettuce; tomato; mayonnaise; mustard.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (the deli standard for a lone protein).

  22. Reuben 89 outstanding

    rye bread (inferred from the name), toasted: corned beef; swiss; sauerkraut; russian dressing.

  23. Roast Beef 89 outstanding (much of this build is inferred)

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: roast beef; lettuce; tomato; mayonnaise; mustard.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (the deli standard for a lone protein).

  24. Salami 89 outstanding (much of this build is inferred)

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: salami; lettuce; tomato; mayonnaise; mustard.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (the deli standard for a lone protein).

  25. Sausalito Turkey not scored: the menu does not describe a sandwich

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: sausalito turkey; lettuce; tomato; mayonnaise; mustard.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (the deli standard for a lone protein).

    Worth a look: named producer: NEW:Sausalito Turkey; ingredient not in the pantry: Sausalito Turkey.

  26. Seafood Salad Sandwich not scored: the menu does not describe a sandwich

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: imitation crab salad; lettuce; tomato; mayonnaise; mustard.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (the deli standard for a lone protein).

    Worth a look: rare in the Bay Area (5 or fewer shops): Imitation Crab (surimi).

  27. Smoked Turkey 84 excellent (much of this build is inferred)

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: smoked turkey; lettuce; tomato; mayonnaise; mustard.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (the deli standard for a lone protein).

  28. Texican Melt 65 very good

    white bread (inferred from the name), toasted: roast beef; cheddar; bbq sauce; bacon.

  29. Tuna 89 outstanding (much of this build is inferred)

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: tuna; lettuce; tomato; mayonnaise; mustard.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (the deli standard for a lone protein).

  30. Tuna Melt 48 rough (much of this build is inferred)

    white bread (inferred from the name), toasted: homemade tuna salad (house-made); choice of cheese.

    Worth a look: house-made: Tuna Salad.

  31. Turkey 84 excellent (much of this build is inferred)

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: turkey; lettuce; tomato; mayonnaise; mustard.

    In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (the deli standard for a lone protein).

  32. Vegetarian 72 very good

    hoagie roll (the menu offers a choice; scored on this one), cold: mayo; mustard; avocado; sprouts; lettuce; tomato; pickles; peppers; onions; cheese.

What you can build

Bread
soft roll, sourdough roll, dutch crunch, whole wheat, white, sourdough, dark rye, light rye
Cheese
cheddar, american, jack, pepperjack, provolone, swiss
Extras
bacon
Produce
avocado, cranberry, jalapeños, sprouts
Protein
salami, ham, corned beef, turkey, tuna, bologna, ny pastrami, chicken breast, mortadella, smoked turkey, maple turkey, pepper turkey, maple ham, sausalito turkey, roast beef, black forest ham
Sauces
bbq sauce, thousand island, yellow mustard, dijon mustard, honey mustard

Menu read 2026-09; items and prices change. The Sandwich Score is the site's opinion of each recipe as the menu lists it, not a review of the shop. Tiers and house-made marks follow the menu's own wording.