Picnicky's Sandwich Shop

Sandwich shop · Vallejo, Solano County

About

• 27on the menu
• 73typical Sandwich Score
• 92best Sandwich Score
• Btier, by the typical sandwich
• 3layers from named producers

Type	Sandwich shop
Where	Vallejo, Solano County, California
Ownership	Independent
On the menu	27 sandwiches
Breads	sour roll, sliced white, sliced sourdough, french roll, sliced rye, wheat roll
Menu read	2026-09

See the menuWebsiteDirections

Logo: Picnicky's Sandwich Shop, from its Facebook page

Where it is

View on OpenStreetMap Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Particularly interesting

• The Sausalito (84): named producer: Turkey; ingredient not in the pantry: Chipotle Sauce
• Ovengold Turkey (68): named producer: Turkey; ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread
• Turkey/Salami (65): named producer: Turkey; ingredient not in the pantry: Jalapeño Spread

The sandwiches

The typical sandwich here scores 73 (the median of 22 scored plainly). 4 items are listed without a number because the menu names them without describing them.

1. Bianco D'Oro Salame not scored: the menu does not describe a sandwich

   hoagie roll (not stated on the menu; inferred), cold: bianco d'oro salame; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; hot pepper spread; garlic spread.

   Worth a look: named producer: Salami; ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread.

2. Cheese Sandwich not scored: the menu does not describe a sandwich

   hoagie roll (not stated on the menu; inferred), cold: up to three types of cheese.

3. Chicken 78 excellent

   hoagie roll (not stated on the menu; inferred), cold: chicken; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; hot pepper spread; garlic spread.

   Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread.

4. Corned Beef Brisket 74 very good

   hoagie roll (not stated on the menu; inferred), cold: corned beef brisket; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; hot pepper spread; garlic spread.

   Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread.

5. Egg Salad not scored: the menu does not describe a sandwich

   hoagie roll (not stated on the menu; inferred), toasted: egg salad.

6. Grand Salammy 85 outstanding

   sour roll, cold: italian dry salami; hard salami; mayo; dijon mustard; lettuce; tomato; pepperoncini.

7. Grilled Cheese Kids 44 rough

   white bread (inferred from the name), toasted: cheese; butter.

   In italics: what the name implies and the menu does not list (grilled cheese as it is served).

8. Hard Salami 77 excellent

   hoagie roll (not stated on the menu; inferred), cold: hard salami; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; hot pepper spread; garlic spread.

   Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread.

9. Hot BLT 84 excellent

   sliced white, toasted: bacon; mayo; lettuce; tomato.

10. Hot Chicken/Pesto 70 very good

    sliced sourdough, toasted: chicken; pesto; mayo; tomato; avocado.

11. Hot Don Coyote 71 very good

    sliced white, toasted: ovengold turkey (named producer); deluxe ham; swiss cheese; mayo; mustard.

    Worth a look: named producer: Turkey.

12. Hot Link Sandwich 78 excellent

    french roll, toasted: hot link; mayo; mustard; lettuce; tomato.

13. Hot Meatball Sandwich 89 outstanding

    french roll, toasted: meatballs; provolone; garlic spread; marinara; red onion.

14. Hot Ruben 89 outstanding

    sliced rye, toasted: corned beef; swiss cheese; sauerkraut; thousand island dressing (low tier).

15. Italian Combo 59 solid

    french roll, cold: italian dry salami; mortadella (high tier); deluxe ham; provolone; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; jalapeno spread; garlic spread.

    Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Jalapeño Spread.

16. London Broil Roast Beef 59 solid (much of this build is inferred)

    hoagie roll (not stated on the menu; inferred), cold: london broil roast beef; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; hot pepper spread; garlic spread.

    Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread.

17. Mesquite Turkey 68 very good

    hoagie roll (not stated on the menu; inferred), cold: mesquite turkey; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; hot pepper spread; garlic spread.

    Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread.

18. Mortadella 60 solid

    hoagie roll (not stated on the menu; inferred), cold: mortadella (high tier); mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; hot pepper spread; garlic spread.

    Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread.

19. Mr. California 57 solid

    wheat roll, cold: avocado; monterey jack; sprouts; tomato; mayo; garlic spread.

20. Ovengold Turkey 68 very good

    hoagie roll (not stated on the menu; inferred), cold: ovengold turkey; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; hot pepper spread; garlic spread.

    Worth a look: named producer: Turkey; ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread.

21. PB&J not scored: the menu does not describe a sandwich

    hoagie roll (not stated on the menu; inferred), cold: peanut butter; jelly.

22. Pastrami 71 very good

    hoagie roll (not stated on the menu; inferred), cold: pastrami; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; hot pepper spread; garlic spread.

    Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread.

23. The Poolboy 71 very good

    sliced white, cold: ovengold turkey (named producer); deluxe ham; lettuce; tomato; bacon; mayo; garlic spread.

    Worth a look: named producer: Turkey.

24. The Sausalito 84 excellent

    sour roll, cold: chipotle; sausalito turkey; pepper jack; lettuce; tomato; ranch (low tier); bacon.

    Worth a look: named producer: Turkey; ingredient not in the pantry: Chipotle Sauce.

25. Tuna Salad 76 excellent

    hoagie roll (not stated on the menu; inferred), cold: tuna salad; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; hot pepper spread; garlic spread.

    Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread.

26. Turkey BLT-A 92 legendary

    sliced sourdough, toasted: ovengold turkey (named producer); bacon; avocado; mayo; lettuce; tomato.

    Worth a look: named producer: Turkey.

27. Turkey/Salami 65 very good

    french roll, cold: ovengold turkey; italian dry salami; cheddar; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; jalapeno spread; garlic spread.

    Worth a look: named producer: Turkey; ingredient not in the pantry: Jalapeño Spread.

What you can build

How it is served

Cold, Hot

Produce

Pickles, Red Onion, Lettuce, Tomato

Protein

Bianco D'Oro Salame, Cheese (up to three types), Chicken, Corned Beef Brisket, Egg Salad, Hard Salami, London Broil Roast Beef, Mesquite Turkey, Mortadella, Ovengold Turkey, Pastrami, Tuna Salad

Sauces

Mayo, Mustard, Hot Pepper Spread, Garlic Spread

The standard build, if you say nothing: mayo, mustard, pickles, red onion, lettuce, tomato, hot pepper spread, garlic spread.

Menu read 2026-09; items and prices change. The Sandwich Score is the site's opinion of each recipe as the menu lists it, not a review of the shop. Tiers and house-made marks follow the menu's own wording.