Sandwich shop · Vallejo, Solano County
About
Picnicky's Sandwich Shop is a sandwich shop in Vallejo, independently owned. The site read its menu and scored every sandwich on it as the menu lists it; what follows is the menu, drawn and scored, not a review.
- Type
- Sandwich shop
- Where
- Vallejo, Solano County, California
- Ownership
- Independent
- On the menu
- 27 sandwiches; the best Sandwich Score is 94
- Breads
- sour roll, sliced white, sliced sourdough, french roll, sliced rye, wheat roll
- Provenance
- 3 from a named producer by the menu's own wording
- Worth a look
- 16 items with something notable
- Menu
- The menu this page was read from, read 2026-09 · Website
- Directions
- On Google Maps
Where it is
View on OpenStreetMap Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.
Particularly interesting
- The Sausalito (84): named producer: Turkey; ingredient not in the pantry: Chipotle Sauce
- Turkey/Salami (65): named producer: Turkey; ingredient not in the pantry: Jalapeño Spread
- Ovengold Turkey (62): named producer: Turkey; ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread
The sandwiches
-
Bianco D'Oro Salame 59 solid
bread not stated, cold: bianco d'oro salame; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; hot pepper spread; garlic spread.
Worth a look: named producer: Salami; ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread.
-
Cheese Sandwich 39 rough
bread not stated, cold: up to three types of cheese.
-
Chicken 70 very good
bread not stated, cold: chicken; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; hot pepper spread; garlic spread.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread.
-
Corned Beef Brisket 67 very good
bread not stated, cold: corned beef brisket; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; hot pepper spread; garlic spread.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread.
-
Egg Salad 39 rough
bread not stated, cold: egg salad.
-
Grand Salammy 85 outstanding
sour roll, cold: italian dry salami; hard salami; mayo; dijon mustard; lettuce; tomato; pepperoncini.
-
Grilled Cheese Kids 44 rough
bread not stated, toasted: cheese.
-
Hard Salami 59 solid
bread not stated, cold: hard salami; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; hot pepper spread; garlic spread.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread.
-
Hot BLT 84 excellent
sliced white, toasted: bacon; mayo; lettuce; tomato.
-
Hot Chicken/Pesto 69 very good
sliced sourdough, toasted: chicken; pesto; mayo; tomato; avocado.
-
Hot Don Coyote 71 very good
sliced white, toasted: ovengold turkey (named producer); deluxe ham; swiss cheese; mayo; mustard.
Worth a look: named producer: Turkey.
-
Hot Link Sandwich 78 excellent
french roll, toasted: hot link; mayo; mustard; lettuce; tomato.
-
Hot Meatball Sandwich 92 legendary
french roll, toasted: meatballs; provolone; garlic spread; marinara; red onion.
-
Hot Ruben 94 legendary
sliced rye, toasted: corned beef; swiss cheese; sauerkraut; thousand island dressing (low tier).
-
Italian Combo 59 solid
french roll, cold: italian dry salami; mortadella (high tier); deluxe ham; provolone; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; jalapeno spread; garlic spread.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Jalapeño Spread.
-
London Broil Roast Beef 51 solid
bread not stated, cold: london broil roast beef; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; hot pepper spread; garlic spread.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread.
-
Mesquite Turkey 62 very good
bread not stated, cold: mesquite turkey; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; hot pepper spread; garlic spread.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread.
-
Mortadella 54 solid
bread not stated, cold: mortadella (high tier); mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; hot pepper spread; garlic spread.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread.
-
Mr. California 56 solid
wheat roll, cold: avocado; monterey jack; sprouts; tomato; mayo; garlic spread.
-
Ovengold Turkey 62 very good
bread not stated, cold: ovengold turkey; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; hot pepper spread; garlic spread.
Worth a look: named producer: Turkey; ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread.
-
PB&J 71 very good
bread not stated, cold: peanut butter; jelly.
-
Pastrami 61 solid
bread not stated, cold: pastrami; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; hot pepper spread; garlic spread.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread.
-
The Poolboy 71 very good
sliced white, cold: ovengold turkey (named producer); deluxe ham; lettuce; tomato; bacon; mayo; garlic spread.
Worth a look: named producer: Turkey.
-
The Sausalito 84 excellent
sour roll, cold: chipotle; sausalito turkey; pepper jack; lettuce; tomato; ranch (low tier); bacon.
Worth a look: named producer: Turkey; ingredient not in the pantry: Chipotle Sauce.
-
Tuna Salad 70 very good
bread not stated, cold: tuna salad; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; hot pepper spread; garlic spread.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Hot Pepper Spread.
-
Turkey BLT-A 87 outstanding
sliced sourdough, cold: ovengold turkey (named producer); bacon; avocado; mayo; lettuce; tomato.
Worth a look: named producer: Turkey.
-
Turkey/Salami 65 very good
french roll, cold: ovengold turkey; italian dry salami; cheddar; mayo; mustard; pickles; red onion; lettuce; tomato; jalapeno spread; garlic spread.
Worth a look: named producer: Turkey; ingredient not in the pantry: Jalapeño Spread.
What you can build
- How it is served
- Cold, Hot
- Produce
- Pickles, Red Onion, Lettuce, Tomato
- Protein
- Bianco D'Oro Salame, Cheese (up to three types), Chicken, Corned Beef Brisket, Egg Salad, Hard Salami, London Broil Roast Beef, Mesquite Turkey, Mortadella, Ovengold Turkey, Pastrami, Tuna Salad
- Sauces
- Mayo, Mustard, Hot Pepper Spread, Garlic Spread
The standard build, if you say nothing: mayo, mustard, pickles, red onion, lettuce, tomato, hot pepper spread, garlic spread.