Sandwich shop · Atherton, San Mateo County
About
The Sandwich Spot Menlo College is a sandwich shop in Atherton, independently owned. The site read its menu and scored every sandwich on it as the menu lists it; what follows is the menu, drawn and scored, not a review.
- Type
- Sandwich shop
- Where
- Atherton, San Mateo County, California
- Ownership
- Independent
- On the menu
- 39 sandwiches; the best Sandwich Score is 88
- Breads
- choice of bread
- Worth a look
- 18 items with something notable
- Menu
- The menu this page was read from, read 2026-09 · Website
- Directions
- On Google Maps
Where it is
View on OpenStreetMap Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors. The exact shop was not found on OpenStreetMap, so the map shows the city.
Particularly interesting
- The Tom Slick (87): ingredient not in the pantry: Bomb Sauce, Secret Sauce
- The Gino Bambion (80): ingredient not in the pantry: Kamikaze Sauce, Secret Sauce
- The Macguire Mansion (80): ingredient not in the pantry: Black Honey, Lava Sauce, Secret Sauce
The sandwiches
-
A Taste Of Broadway 54 solid
choice of bread, cold: ham; salami; prosciutto (high tier); provolone; italian dressing; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
-
Ayoush 58 solid
choice of bread, cold: veggies; avocado; cucumber; black olives; cream cheese; artichoke hearts; roasted red peppers; chutney or pesto sauce; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Mixed Vegetables, Secret Sauce.
-
Grazie Arron 73 very good
choice of bread, toasted: hot turkey; cranberry; cream cheese; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
-
Lean Mean Veggie Machine 50 solid
choice of bread, cold: veggies; avocado; cucumber; black olives; carrots; hummus; lava sauce; choice of cheese; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Mixed Vegetables, Lava Sauce, Secret Sauce.
-
Sophia Mia 75 very good
choice of bread, toasted: marinated chicken; psycho sauce; jack cheese; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Psycho Sauce, Secret Sauce.
-
Station 9 71 very good
choice of bread, toasted: hot salami; bomb sauce; pepper jack; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Bomb Sauce, Secret Sauce.
-
The 40 Year Old Virgin 72 very good
choice of bread, toasted: hot turkey; bacon; cheddar; french fried onion strips; panic sauce; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Panic Sauce, Secret Sauce.
-
The Backwards Burger 70 very good
choice of bread, toasted: hot roast beef; 1000 island dressing; melted cheddar; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
-
The Bob & Vivian 44 rough
choice of bread, toasted: salami; bacon; ham; cream cheese; honey mustard (low tier); kassi sauce; bomb sauce; chronic caesar sauce (low tier); mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Bomb Sauce, Secret Sauce.
-
The Bombastic 63 very good
choice of bread, toasted: marinated chicken; hot sauce (low tier); bomb sauce; pepper jack; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Bomb Sauce, Secret Sauce.
-
The Bumgarner 71 very good
choice of bread, toasted: marinated chicken; bacon; cheddar; panic sauce; french fried onion strips; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Panic Sauce, Secret Sauce.
-
The Courtyard Deluxe 72 very good
choice of bread, toasted: roast beef; bacon; bbq sauce; cheddar; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
-
The Dray Magic 78 excellent
choice of bread, toasted: hot pastrami; bacon; chipotle aioli; choice of cheese; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
-
The El Camino 63 very good
choice of bread, toasted: marinated chicken; hot sauce (low tier); blue cheese dressing; pepper jack; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
-
The Farmer's Market 68 very good
choice of bread, cold: veggies; avocado; cucumber; sprouts; cheddar; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Mixed Vegetables, Secret Sauce.
-
The Flaming Cougar 62 very good
choice of bread, toasted: hot pastrami; sauerkraut; swiss; 1000 island dressing; kamikaze sauce; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Kamikaze Sauce, Secret Sauce.
-
The Foxy Lady 77 excellent
choice of bread, toasted: marinated chicken; bbq sauce; jack cheese; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
-
The GSU 44 rough
choice of bread, toasted: marinated chicken; black olives; pepper jack; kassi garlic sauce; chronic caesar sauce (low tier); mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
-
The Giants Combo 62 very good
choice of bread, cold: turkey; ham; roast beef; jack cheese; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
-
The Gino Bambion 80 excellent
choice of bread, toasted: hot roast beef; bacon; cream cheese; kamikaze sauce; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Kamikaze Sauce, Secret Sauce.
-
The Godfather Penna 48 rough
choice of bread, toasted: marinated chicken; marinara; black olives; provolone; salami; kassi garlic sauce; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
-
The Hangover 59 solid
choice of bread, toasted: hot turkey; bacon; cream cheese; avocado; kassi sauce; bomb sauce; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Bomb Sauce, Secret Sauce.
-
The Hasta La Vista 73 very good
choice of bread, toasted: hot turkey; avocado; bomb sauce; cream cheese; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Bomb Sauce, Secret Sauce.
-
The Holy Pope 76 excellent
choice of bread, toasted: hot turkey; ham; swiss; pomegranate glaze; dill weed; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Pomegranate Glaze, Secret Sauce.
-
The Italiano 43 rough
choice of bread, toasted: marinated chicken; provolone; artichoke hearts; fire roasted red pepper strips; kassi sauce; pesto oregano sauce; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
-
The Jailbird 68 very good
choice of bread, toasted: marinated chicken; cranberry; bomb sauce; pepper jack; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Bomb Sauce, Secret Sauce.
-
The K9er 80 excellent
choice of bread, toasted: hot roast beef; bbq sauce; jack cheese; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
-
The Macguire Mansion 80 excellent
choice of bread, toasted: marinated chicken; bacon; black honey; jack cheese; lava spicy sauce; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Black Honey, Lava Sauce, Secret Sauce.
-
The Manwich 68 very good
choice of bread, toasted: hot pastrami; roast beef; salami; swiss; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
-
The OMG 76 excellent
choice of bread, toasted: marinated chicken; teriyaki; pineapple; jack cheese; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
-
The Pastrami Mami 78 excellent
choice of bread, toasted: hot pastrami; provolone; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
-
The Pineapple Express 76 excellent
choice of bread, toasted: hot ham; pineapple; swiss; teriyaki sauce; tropical poppy seed sauce; lava spicy sauce; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Poppy Seed Dressing, Lava Sauce, Secret Sauce.
-
The RWC Baller 69 very good
choice of bread, toasted: meatballs; marinara; provolone; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
-
The Rockin' Reuben 62 very good
choice of bread, toasted: pastrami; sauerkraut; 1000 island dressing; swiss; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
-
The Smokin' Sequoia 74 very good
choice of bread, toasted: hot turkey; bacon; cheddar; avocado; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
-
The Tom Slick 87 outstanding
choice of bread, toasted: hot roast beef; bomb sauce; cream cheese; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
Worth a look: ingredient not in the pantry: Bomb Sauce, Secret Sauce.
-
The Train Wreck 71 very good
choice of bread, toasted: hot turkey; prosciutto (high tier); avocado; swiss; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
-
The Triple Threat 88 outstanding
choice of bread, toasted: Bacon; Lettuce; Tomato; Avocado; Mayonnaise; Mustard; Secret Sauce; Pickle (cucumber); Onion; Pepper (bell/hot).
-
The Woodside Wildcat 72 very good
choice of bread, toasted: marinated chicken; bacon; avocado; pepper jack; mayo; mustard; secret sauce; lettuce; tomato; pickles; onions; peppers.
What you can build
- Bread
- Dutch Crunch Roll, Sourdough Roll, Sweet French Roll, Wheat Roll, Sliced Wheat, Sliced Light Rye, Sliced Sourdough, Gluten Free Wrap
- Cheese
- Swiss, Cheddar, Pepper Jack, Provolone, American
- Extras
- Bacon, Avocado, French Fried Onion Strips, Cranberry, Cream Cheese, Full Portion Meat, Half Portion Meat, Cheese
- How it is served
- Hot, Cold
- Produce
- Lettuce, Tomato, Pickles, Onions, Peppers
- Protein
- Turkey, Roast Beef, Ham, Salami, Pastrami, Prosciutto, Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad
- Sauces
- Mayo, Mustard, Secret Sauce
The standard build, if you say nothing: mayo, mustard, secret sauce, lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions, peppers.