· 3 min read

Croque-Tartiflette

Thin potato rounds, ham, Reblochon and béchamel between buttered bread, broiled until the crust crackles: the Savoyard tartiflette folded into a hot Croque.

Croque-Tartiflette: an illustration of potato, onion and béchamel on white bread.
Illustration, AI-generated

At a glance

  • Bread: Pain de mie or sandwich bread, buttered on the outside
  • Filling: Cooked potato slices, Reblochon, baked ham, a smear of mustard
  • Sauce: Béchamel inside the sandwich and a spoonful on top
  • Method: Broiled about 5 minutes a side, served hot
  • Borrowed from: Tartiflette, the Savoyard potato, lardon and Reblochon gratin
  • Origin: Savoie by ancestry; the sandwich's own date is unrecorded

Every croque-tartiflette begins at the stove, before any bread is touched. Red-skinned potatoes are boiled until a knife slides through and cut into thin rounds, two for each sandwich, because raw potato would still be chalky when the bread was already gold. Mustard goes on the bread first, then thinly sliced baked ham, the potato, two slices of Reblochon and a spoonful of béchamel, and a second slice of buttered bread closes the stack with the butter facing out. The slices stay thin for a practical reason: a thick round tilts the stack and lets the cheese slide out the edge under the broiler.

The broiler is set low, and each side takes roughly five minutes. The butter on the outside browns into a thin, brittle crust that crackles when a knife starts through, and underneath it the crumb of the pain de mie stays soft and a little steamy. The béchamel pins the potato in place and keeps it moist, so the middle eats as a creamy layer. A last spoonful goes on top, still pale against the toasted crust, and runs slowly down the sides on the walk to the table, so the first bite is half crisp edge and half warm sauce.

Reblochon supplies the character. It comes from the Aravis valleys of Haute-Savoie, a soft cow's-milk wheel with a rind washed in brine, and that rind gives off a cellar-and-hay smell as soon as it warms. Under heat the paste turns glossy and stretches in short strands when the sandwich is pulled apart, and the flavor is milky and faintly nutty with a sticky, savory edge near the rind. A folk story traces the name to reblocher, to pinch the cow a second time, a trick herdsmen supposedly used to hold back milk from the landowner's measure. The tale is widely told and hard to verify, but the second milking is the fattier one, which fits the cheese's richness.

The casserole this sandwich descends from is built on lardons and sweated onion, and the sandwich recipes in circulation put baked ham in their place, since ham slices flat and fits between bread without a pan of its own. A cook who misses the bacon can fry lardons with the onion first and fold them into the béchamel. Mustard sharpens the cheese from below. Cheese swaps are easy to imagine, since Beaufort and Abondance are Savoyard cheeses that melt well, and one widely copied version names Cantal in its method while listing Reblochon in its ingredients, a slip that shows how loosely the cheese is treated once the sandwich leaves the Alps.

It is eaten hot and fast. The first cut releases a wave of warm cheese smell, the butter crust gives with a short snap, and the potato and ham settle into a thick cream that coats the roof of the mouth. One hand holds it, and the filling stays together long enough to be carried to a table or a desk. Mustard cuts through the cream on the second bite, and the edge of the Reblochon rind, browned against the pan, tastes of toasted milk and salt. A glass of dry Savoie white wine is the natural pairing, the way it is for the casserole.

Origin and history

The cook who first put tartiflette between bread is unknown. The recipe travels in English-language collections of French dishes, always in the same eight-ingredient build for four sandwiches: mustard, béchamel, bread, ham, cooked red potato, Reblochon and butter. That shared list suggests one printed original that later copies reproduced, and it is the form in which most cooks outside Savoie have met the sandwich.

The dish it is named for has a better paper trail. Tartiflette is a Savoyard gratin descended from the péla, a potato and cheese dish cooked in a long-handled pan, and its name probably comes from tartifles or the Arpitan tartiflâ, words for potato. The modern Reblochon version began to appear on ski-resort menus in the 1980s. A popular story says the Reblochon trade body, the Syndicat Interprofessionnel du Reblochon, invented it to move stock; the Syndicat's director, Lucile Marton, has disputed that account while acknowledging that the cheese profited.

That puts the earliest possible croque-tartiflette in the 1980s, when the gratin first reached ski-resort menus. The Syndicat published its own recipe in the late 1990s, adapting the péla to Reblochon that was slightly too runny to sell whole, and the sandwich then took the same three ingredients out of the baking dish and pressed them between buttered bread.

Build this sandwich

Load its stack into the Sandwich Builder. Swap a layer, watch the score move.

Open in the builder

Read next