At a glance
- Cheese: Fresh chèvre, spread or sliced from a log
- Nut: Walnut halves or pieces, ideally this season's crop
- Sweet note: Honey, in the Paul and regional-bakery builds
- Bread: Baguette half, focaccia or a soft sandwich loaf, depending on the counter
- Where it sells: Bakery-chain and boulangerie lunch counters across France
- Served: Cold from the display case; warmed, the same cheese becomes a chèvre chaud toast
Paul builds its version on focaccia and spreads honey on the bread first, so the sweetness meets the crumb before any cheese does. Goat cheese goes over it, then marinated semi-dried tomatoes, walnuts and spinach shoots. The sandwich is vegetarian, sold as a nouveauté, rated at about 537 kcal, and intended for eating on the day it is bought. The first taste is honey, the cheese's lactic sourness follows, and the walnut skin adds a dry bitterness on the way out. The tomatoes bring a chewy acid note and the spinach a wet green one, and the walnut stays the only brittle thing in the build, so the jaw registers it last.
A walnut half splits between the molars and releases a papery bitterness from its skin, then the cool, tangy chèvre closes over it, so each bite starts hard and ends soft. The failures are specific. A stale walnut has gone rancid in its own oil and tastes of soap against the cheese. Crumbs ground too fine vanish into the spread and take the crunch with them. Chèvre spread wet onto a soft crumb soaks it through by midday, which is why a display-case sandwich leans on an oiled focaccia or a crusty baguette, and why a thin film of honey or butter on the cut face works as a seal.
A bakery near the Swiss border sells the same idea in plainer clothes: goat cheese, green salad, walnuts from its own region, local honey and a mayonnaise sauce, on white or seeded bread. It is withdrawn from sale from 23 to 25 December. The mayonnaise gives the salad leaves a coat that the honey would otherwise have to provide, and the regional walnuts carry the sandwich's only claim to place.
Walnut quality varies more than cheese quality does, and this sandwich shows it. Walnuts harvested in early autumn taste milky and faintly sweet for a few weeks, and the longer they sit the drier and more tannic they turn. France grows walnuts under protected names, Grenoble and Périgord among them, and a bakery that lists local walnuts is pointing at that supply. A chèvre-noix made in October with a fresh crop tastes like a different product from one made in spring with nuts held since the harvest, because the walnut is carrying the bitterness the whole build depends on.
The sandwich belongs to the lunch hour at a bakery, in the same case as the jambon-beurre and the quiche. Chèvre spreads without cooking and keeps its tang when cold, and the walnut gives the filling the chew that ham gets from meat. Warm the same cheese under a grill and it slumps into the chèvre chaud toast of the salad menu, soft where this one cracks. Eaten at a desk or on a bench, the cold version leaves goat cheese and honey on the tongue and a few walnut flakes on the paper, and the crunch is gone before the second half is.
Origin and history
Nobody is credited with the sandwich, and the listings are all retail ones: a focaccia on Paul's menu, a chèvre-miel-noix sandwich at a border-country bakery, and similar builds in bakery cases across France. Goat cheese, walnuts and honey are three pantry items that sit together on any French cheese board, and a baker assembling a cold lunch sandwich from them needs no stove and no sauce pan.
Both listings carry the same two ingredients and then diverge on the third element. Paul puts a honey spread under the cheese and adds tomatoes and spinach shoots to a focaccia; the bakery near the border adds salad, mayonnaise and local honey to white or seeded bread. The goat cheese and the walnut are the fixed pair, and the rest of the build follows whatever the counter has on its shelves.
The border bakery gives the sandwich its most specific working schedule. It is made to order for pickup from 4 a.m. on Mondays and Fridays, about 900 metres from the Swiss customs post, and it carries a 48-hour limit in the refrigerator.