Ingredients
At a glance
- Base: Soft cooked poha, then spiced sprouted moth bean usal under a lighter, rounded tarri
- Topping: Farsan, thin chivda and sev, onion, lemon, coriander
- Bread: Soft pav, or sliced white bread at the old Peth houses
- Setting: Pune's old Peth quarters, eaten as breakfast or an afternoon plate
- Documented: Shri Krishna Bhuvan, Tulshibaug, reported open since 1941
- Country: India (Pune, Maharashtra)
The plate comes to a Pune table with a mound of soft yellow poha sitting under the crunch, the first clue that this is something other than a bowl of straight usal. Flattened rice is cooked down with turmeric and onion until it is tender and faintly sweet, spooned into the dish, and covered with a thin gravy of sprouted moth beans. Over that go farsan, a handful of fine chivda and fine sev, raw onion, coriander and a wedge of lemon. The steam carries turmeric and fried onion up toward the eater before the spoon goes in, and the spoon meets a soft layer, then beans, then a ceiling of crisp things that has not yet gone limp.
The tarri, which many Pune counters call the sample, is ladled over at the last second and decides how the plate eats. In the Pune houses it is built from onion, tomato, garlic and ginger cooked with a dry-roasted blend of coriander, cumin, clove, pepper and dried red chilli, and it runs thinner and gentler than the oil-slicked red of Kolhapur. The heat arrives in a slow build after a few mouthfuls, with a faint sweetness underneath. The poha drinks some of that gravy and turns custardy at the base, while the farsan at the top keeps its snap for the first ten minutes or so. Stir it all together early and the plate becomes one soft porridge.
Bread does the scooping. Tear a piece of soft, fresh pav across the middle, press the gravy and poha into the fold, and the sandwich assembles itself a bite at a time in the hand, with the torn crumb carrying a little of every layer. Day-old pav sits on the gravy and refuses to take it up. Shri Krishna Bhuvan, one of the oldest houses, sends sliced white bread to the table with its misal, and the slices soak differently: the crumb drinks the coconut-rounded tarri quickly, while the crust holds long enough to scoop the poha.
A Puneri plate depends on order and timing at the counter. The usal stays warm in a wide vessel while the farsan and sev are scooped from open tubs at the last moment, so the plate goes together in seconds and is best eaten at once. Eaten at a standing counter, it is a breakfast that finishes before the tea arrives; at a seated Peth hotel with a steel plate and a glass of buttermilk or kokum sharbat beside it, it stretches into an afternoon snack. The crunch is audible two seats away, a dry crackle as the spoon cuts through, and the onion bites cold against the warm beans.
Inside the city the differences sit in the gravy and the topping. Vaidya Upahar Gruha ladles a green curry of fresh chillies, coconut, ginger, green tomato and tamarind, and sends no lemon wedge because the tamarind already supplies the sourness. Shri Krishna Bhuvan stirs coconut into a red tarri and tucks a spoon of potato bhaji beneath the poha. Katakirr in Karve Nagar sits at the hot end, with a secret-recipe gravy that has a reputation as the sharpest in town, and Bedekar offers an upvas misal for fasting days.
Origin and history
Misal itself is placed by several food writers in the Nashik and Khandesh belt, with Pune taking it up later in the last century, and no record dates the moment poha joined the bowl in the Pune houses. What survives is a set of shop dates. Vaidya Upahar Gruha on Budhwar Peth gives 1910 as its founding year and is described as the oldest running misal house in the city, a claim that rests on the family's own account. Bedekar Tea Stall in Narayan Peth began in 1948 selling tea and pakoras and added misal afterwards, under the founder's son.
Both houses serve usal and poha under farsan and onion, one with a green coconut-and-tamarind gravy and the other with a red one that tastes slightly sweet before its pungency builds. Pav is reported to have become the usual bread in Pune only around the 1970s, which would explain why sliced loaf still turns up at the oldest tables.
The firmest date belongs to Shri Krishna Bhuvan in Tulshibaug, reported open since 1941. It makes the mild end of the Pune range, a coconut-rounded red tarri ladled over cooked poha and potato bhaji, finished with chivda and sev, and served with sliced white bread. Pune families are reported to bring it home on Sunday mornings in a steel container for the family breakfast.