· 3 min read

Panino con Focaccia Ripiena

Messina's schiacciata con la tuma: two thin sheets of dough sealed around tuma, greens, tomato and anchovy, baked in a tray and sold hot.

Panino con Focaccia Ripiena: an illustration of olive oil on focaccia.
Illustration, AI-generated

At a glance

  • Form: Two thin sheets of leavened dough sealed around a raw filling and baked in one tray
  • Filling: Tuma, escarole or broccoli, fresh tomato, anchovy fillets
  • Finish: Lid brushed with olive oil and pricked so steam can leave
  • Eaten: Hot from the bakery or rosticceria, any hour
  • Current recipe: Postwar Messina, with fresh tomato and diced tuma
  • Country: Italy (Messina, Sicily)

In a Messina bakery the schiacciata con la tuma starts as two discs of leavened dough rolled about half a centimetre thick. One lines an oiled tray and climbs the sides, the raw filling goes on top, the second disc closes it, and the baker pinches the rim shut, brushes the lid with oil and pricks it with a fork. That last step has a job: the filling gives off steam in the oven, and the holes let it leave without lifting the lid into a balloon. What comes out is a slab with a blistered gold top, a rim gone hard and nutty, and a seam that shows where the two sheets fused.

The filling is built to cook inside bread. Tuma, the fresh, mild Sicilian cheese, is diced so it softens evenly and drags into strings at the first bite, hot enough to scald an impatient tongue. Escarole or broccoli wilts under the lid and keeps a faint bitter edge, tomato sheds its juice into the crumb, and anchovy fillets melt into the cheese until the salt reads as depth, a savoury smell that drifts out of the bakery door well before the tray is cut. The underside of the dough drinks that juice and turns tender and a little dense, while the top stays crisp.

The schiacciata is street food, sold hot in the bakeries, rosticcerie and pasticcerie of Messina at any hour of the day, and families bake it at home for lunch or dinner as well. The sealed sheets suit eating on the move, since the cheese stays inside the dough until the first bite goes through the lid, and a piece cut from the tray is still giving off steam as it is opened. The sound is a short crackle, then the give of soft crumb, then a salty, milky heat from the middle that carries the anchovy long after the vegetable has faded.

The same filling turns up in the pidone, a folded half-moon of dough that is fried where the schiacciata is baked, so the city treats cheese, greens and anchovy as one idea that can be wrapped in different doughs. Beyond Messina the filling bends with the town: Catania keeps just anchovy and tuma, a Christmas version adds sausage and cauliflower or broccoli, and Caltanissetta makes a richer pie with sausage, boiled spinach, pecorino and olives, its dough enriched with potato and egg.

Moisture decides whether the tray works. Tomato is the risk, because juice that cannot escape soaks the lower sheet and can split the seam, and that is why the pricked lid and the leafy vegetables matter: escarole and tuma take up liquid as they cook, and the dough drinks the rest. Traditional bakeries use a wood-fired oven, which gives the lid its colour and a touch of char at the rim. A slower bake in a modern oven is how at least one Messina shop gets there. Whichever oven is used, the aim is a molten centre under a golden lid.

Origin and history

Fresh tomato and diced tuma entered the schiacciata after the Second World War, and that postwar recipe is the one Messina bakeries sell today. The dish itself began as a country household's way of turning flour, cheese, greens and anchovy into a meal, and the sealed sheets of dough made a small amount of filling go a long way.

Bakers in the city also make the focaccia messinese, an open tray bread topped with escarole, tomato, anchovy and tuma, and the two are often described together. The schiacciata is the one that closes its filling between two sheets of dough, and that sealing step makes it a stuffed bread, a sandwich in the Italian sense of a filling held in dough.

The bakery L'Ancora dal 1968, on Viale della Libertà in Messina, makes its version with tuma, vegetables, tomato and anchovies between two layers of dough. The lid is brushed with extra virgin olive oil and pricked, and the tray is baked slowly so the centre stays molten. The shop opens at seven in the morning and has the schiacciata ready through the day.

Build this sandwich

Load its stack into the Sandwich Builder. Swap a layer, watch the score move.

Open in the builder

Read next