· 3 min read

Cheesesteak Wit

Wit means onions fried on the flat-top and chopped through the beef. At Pat's King of Steaks the cheese is named first and the onion second: "Whiz wit."

Cheesesteak Wit: an illustration of beef, cheese sauce and onion on hoagie roll.
Illustration, AI-generated

At a glance

  • Call: Cheese named first, then wit, as in "Whiz wit" or "provolone wit"
  • Onions: Sliced thin, fried on the flat-top, chopped through the beef
  • Meat: Thinly sliced beef, chopped and seared on the same steel
  • Bread: A long, crusted Italian-style roll, typically from Amoroso's
  • Counter: Pat's King of Steaks, 9th Street and Passyunk Avenue, South Philadelphia
  • Dated anchor: Pat Olivieri's beef-and-onion sandwich, 1930

The cook at the Pat's King of Steaks window, on the corner of 9th Street and Passyunk Avenue, hears two words from a customer who knows the drill: the cheese, then "wit." The second word means onions, sliced thin and fried on the same flat-top where the beef is chopped, and it turns an order for steak and cheese into steak, cheese and a heap of slumped, sweet onion folded all the way through. The cook drops the onions on the steel a minute ahead of the meat, so they have started to brown by the time the beef lands, and two spatulas chop the pair together until strands of beef and strands of onion are the same length.

Onion changes what the meat does on the steel. Rendered beef fat pools around it, the slices sop up the fat and give back their own water, and the pile turns into a glossy, loose tangle that holds the cheese instead of letting it slide off. The sizzle drops a register as the onion water cooks away, and a sweet, almost burnt-sugar steam rolls off the griddle and down the sidewalk where the line stands. Onion that goes on late stays pale and sharp, and its water runs into the crumb of the roll, which is why a cook who knows the order starts the onions first and leaves them alone.

The roll meets all of this at the seam. A long roll, crackling outside and soft and open within, typically an Amoroso's at Pat's, takes the hot filling in one scoop, and the steam from the onion softens the inner face of the bread while the outside stays crisp. The wax paper darkens with fat before the sandwich leaves the window. The first bite arrives too hot, with threads of onion hanging out of the end and cheese stretching back toward the paper, and the onion's sweetness cuts the salt of the Whiz or the sharpness of the provolone. A witout keeps the cheese alone with the beef, and the onion strands are the difference you taste.

At the window the order has a grammar, and "wit" is its second slot. Pat's posts the pattern for first-timers: name the cheese, then say wit or witout, so "Whiz wit" and "American witout" are complete sentences. The word is Philadelphia's pronunciation of with, spelled the way it is said, and the counter treats it as a verb phrase that closes the order. Tourists rehearse it in the line that runs out onto the pavement, and a stumble at the window costs the cook a second, which is why the shops post the rules in plain view. Geno's, opened across the street in 1966, runs the same two-slot call.

The cook's judgment sits in the onion. Fried too briefly, onions leave a raw, sulfurous bite and a wet patch in the roll. Pushed too long on a hot steel, they scorch to black flecks that taste bitter against the beef, and a crowded griddle on a busy night makes both mistakes easier. A line cook holding a loaded flat-top keeps the onions moving to the cooler edge, then drags them back under the meat at the last moment. The sandwich that lands in a customer's hand tells the story: soft, sweet onion that has gone translucent, no pale crescents, no black ones.

Origin and history

Pat Olivieri ran a hot dog stand at the South Philadelphia corner where Pat's still stands, and the date the shop gives for his first steak sandwich is 1930, with some accounts placing it a few years later. Most tellings put the original on a roll with chopped beef and fried onions, cooked on the hot dog griddle. Cheese is absent from that first version in nearly every account, and the onions are present.

The cheese came after. The sandwich's cheese history carries two stories: a Pat's manager named Joe Lorenza, remembered as "Cocky Joe," is credited with putting provolone on a steak sometime between the 1940s and 1951, and Geno's founder Joe Vento later claimed the idea for himself. Kraft launched Cheez Whiz in 1952, and the jar reached the Pat's griddle in the 1950s, with Frank Olivieri Sr. named as the cook who first used it. No record dates the first customer to say "wit" at a window.

What survives is the sequence on the steel. Onions were frying under Pat Olivieri's beef in 1930, a decade or more before any cheese, and the word at the window has marked the onion as a choice ever since. The call runs backward from the cook's side: the cheese is named first, but the onions are the part that went down first.

Build this sandwich

Load its stack into the Sandwich Builder. Swap a layer, watch the score move.

Open in the builder

Read next

Veggie Wrap at Dimond Cafe

Romaine, crumbled feta cheese, kalamata olives, bell peppers, cucumbers, tomatoes, avocado, balsamic dressing on spinach wrap. Sandwich Score 69, very good. At Dimond Cafe, Oakland.

Andrew Lekashman
Andrew Lekashman
· 2 min read

Veggie at Dimond Cafe

Garden patty, swiss cheese, avocado, lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles, garlic aioli sauce on Burger Bun. Sandwich Score 80, excellent. At Dimond Cafe, Oakland.

Andrew Lekashman
Andrew Lekashman
· 2 min read