At a glance
- Bread: Long Philadelphia-style hoagie roll, soft inside with a thin crust
- Protein: Chopped griddled beef, usually ribeye or trimmings
- Peppers: Sliced green bell peppers in most shops; sweet or hot "long hots" on request
- Cheese: Cheez Whiz, American, or provolone, melted over the beef
- Method: Peppers cooked down on the flat-top beside the meat
- Where: Philadelphia steak shops, and anywhere else that sells a cheesesteak
A cook at a Philadelphia steak shop slides a handful of sliced green peppers onto the flat-top next to the pile of beef, and for the first minute nothing about them looks edible: stiff, wet, bright. The steel hisses and they slump. By the time the edges have gone brown and the rims have blistered, the kitchen smells grassy and sweet, a green note laid over the roasting-fat smell of the beef, and the peppers have lost their crunch without turning to mush. That is the pepper steak: a chopped beef-and-cheese sandwich with a vegetable cooked into the mass instead of dropped on top at the end.
Most shops reach for bell peppers, cut into strips or half-moons and fried until they give. Some sell long hots as well, the thin, wrinkled Italian frying peppers that taste green and mild at the stem and turn sharp toward the tip, and a cook who puts them on the steel adds a bite that cuts through melted cheese the way pickled peppers cut through a beef gravy. Cooked wit onions or without, the peppers share the steel and the grease, and the cook folds everything together with the beef so each forkful of the chopped pile carries all of it.
Bite in and heat comes first, the whole roll warm through and the cheese still loose. Then the pepper gives a vegetal sweetness that sits between the salt of the beef and the thick richness of the Whiz or American, and a slightly bitter edge where the skin charred. A long hot sharpens that edge into a slow burn at the back of the throat. The roll is soft enough to flatten under the thumb and tough enough to keep a wet filling from running down the wrist. Peppers release water as they cook, so a cook who rushes them hands over a roll that soaks through at the bottom in a minute and a half.
Whether peppers belong on a cheesesteak at all has been a minor local fight for years. Asked in January 2018, Frank Olivieri of Pat's King of Steaks answered with a flat "NO," yet Pat's has offered peppers for decades and they are on roughly 40 percent of its orders. Chubby's put the figure near 25 percent, Barry's near one in five, and Jim's South Street, which Ken Silver said has offered them since the early days, about 25 percent. Joey Vento, the founder of Geno's, had refused them for years; Geno's now lists them. The pattern has a consistent shape: the shop owners defend a tradition of onions and cheese, and the customer at the window orders peppers anyway.
The ordering vocabulary shows how ordinary they are. A customer says "Whiz wit" for Cheez Whiz and onions, and peppers go on as one more add-on at the window, the way a diner at a pizzeria asks for mushrooms. Out-of-towners ask more often than locals: at the Center City branch of Steve's Prince of Steaks about 60 percent of orders carry peppers, mostly from visitors, and the owner family says most Philadelphians skip them. The pizza steak adds marinara and mozzarella to the same chopped base, and a mushroom cheesesteak slides sauteed caps under the cheese, but the pepper version is the one that gets asked for at the counter by someone who has never eaten there before.
Origin and History
No record names who first put a pepper on a Philadelphia steak sandwich. The better-documented history belongs to the cheese: Pat's, the 1930 stand on South Philadelphia's Passyunk Avenue, sold its chopped steak without any, and a manager is credited with adding provolone sometime in the 1940s, while Cheez Whiz arrived later still, as Ken Silver pointed out.
The peppers slotted into a sandwich that was already changing. By the time anyone counted, they rode on about one order in four at several well-known shops and on roughly two in five at the stand that started it all, an adoption that happened at the counter, one extra at a time.
The sharpest turn is at Geno's, directly across the intersection from Pat's. Its founder Joey Vento turned peppers down for years, and by 2018 the griddle there cooked them on request, so both corners of the most famous crossing in cheesesteak country now sell the sandwich their owners once argued against.